kilonad wrote:
You may find this document on offset parabolic dish design to be of some use. It's got lots of good diagrams and equations in it.
http://www.w1ghz.org/antbook/chap5.pdfI had this idea myself a year or two ago, and I came to the conclusion that it would be rather pointless. In addition to being really hard to implement with an umbrella structure, it would also be very inefficient unless you found a way to pre-focus all of the light from your strobe onto the reflector fabric.
Even in the worst case scenario (the 42" PLM), the central spot shadow takes up a mere 2.5% of the reflector area. By the time you get to the 86" PLM, you're looking at 0.7%. If the objects you're shooting are specular enough to show a clear reflection of the PLM, you'd be better off using the diffusion fabric on it anyway.
Great link and observations. I think it would be easier to direct a receiver at the dish properly than to light it with a flash . . . getting 100% of the light to perfectly hit the dish, without spill, using an umbrella-like structure would be a huge undertaking. As you say, PLM can direct and focus nearly 100% of the light, with no spill. Conventional back loaded reflectors can only focus around 60% of the light and always have spill, unless gridded.
PLM V2 (about 6 weeks away) actually uses a speedring to put the flash dead-on-axis and the focus is more controllable. An Elinchrom speedring is also being made, and it has an adjustable 7mm shaft that doesn't protrude behind the light (if used without the speed ring.) I will be filing a patent on this design.
For ultimate long distance, we have a 22" polished aluminum front-loaded dish reflector in production right now that is focusable down to about 6° and produces incredible narrow beam output, or nearly incredible output beams up to around 30°. Info coming soon. Uses the same speedring assembly as PLM V2.